Buying stones online safely: checks and warning signs

← Back to Recognizing real stones

What a photo does not show, the information to insist on, warning signs, your rights as a remote buyer and the steps to take when the parcel arrives.

Key points

PrincipleA photo does not prove the nature of a stone: the listing, the seller and the price matter too
To insist onExact nature, treatment, dimensions in millimetres, weight in grams, photo of the actual piece or an “indicative” mention
WithdrawalFor distance selling, a period of at least 14 days to withdraw from the purchase (general rule)
Statutory guaranteeLegal conformity guarantee of at least two years for goods (European rule)
Valuable piecesCertificate from a recognised gemmological laboratory, detailed invoice
Reporting a problemOfficial platform SignalConso, DGCCRF

What the photo does not tell you

Buying stones online means buying without touching, without weighing and without looking under a loupe. Yet a natural stone is unique: its colour, veins and inclusions vary from one piece to another. A photo, even an honest one, has several limits:

  • colour depends on the screen, the studio lighting and retouching;
  • size is hard to judge without a reference: a 4 cm sphere and an 8 cm sphere look alike on screen;
  • weight cannot be seen, yet it is a valuable clue (a piece that is light for its size may be plastic);
  • transparency, fractures and feel cannot be perceived;
  • the photo may be of a model or a stock image, not of the piece you receive.

The consequence is simple: the written listing matters at least as much as the photo, and it is better to understand what you are buying than to rely on appearance.

The eight checks before buying

  1. The exact nature. A mineral name (“rose quartz”, “howlite”), not just a colour or an evocative name (“sun stone”, “Brazilian crystal”).
  2. The treatment. The words “natural”, “dyed”, “heated”, “stabilised”, “reconstituted”, “synthetic” (see how to read a label).
  3. Dimensions in millimetres and weight in grams. You can compare them with the parcel using a ruler and a kitchen scale.
  4. The photo. Is it the piece you will receive, or an indicative photo? For a valuable unique piece, ask for a photo of the exact piece, under several lights.
  5. The origin. Useful but to be treated with caution: a stated country is never guaranteed without documents.
  6. The metal and the setting for jewellery: 925 silver (92.5% silver), gold-plated, steel, brass; see the metals used in jewellery.
  7. The seller. Full legal notices (name, address, contact details, company registration number), a way to reach a real person, and clear delivery times.
  8. Returns. Withdrawal conditions, who pays for the return, refund timeframe. See returns and refunds.

Warning signs

SignWhat it may meanWhat to do
A very low price for a large rare piece (large lapis or turquoise sphere, large amethyst)Imitation, glass, reconstitution, or treated material without disclosureAsk for the exact nature; compare with other sellers
Very saturated and very uniform colourDye or glassAsk whether the colour is natural
An exotic name with no mineral (“crystal stone”, “energy stone”)Sale of glass, resin or reconstituted stone under a vague nameAsk for the name of the mineral
No dimensions, no weightPhoto only; impossible to verifyAsk for measurements before buying
Stock photos, identical across several shopsThe piece you receive may be differentAsk for a photo of the real piece
“Certificate of authenticity” with no laboratoryPaper issued by the seller itselfAsk for the laboratory name and the report number
Missing or vague legal noticesSeller hard to reach if there is a problemWalk away, or buy through a service that protects the buyer
Reviews that all sound alike, with no detail or photosUnreliable reviewsLook for detailed reviews with customer photos on third-party sites

These signs never prove on their own that a seller is dishonest: they are there to prompt questions. An honest seller answers without difficulty.

Your rights, in general terms

This information is general and does not constitute legal advice.

  • Right of withdrawal. For a distance purchase, French and European law generally gives 14 days to withdraw from the purchase, counted from receipt of the goods, with exceptions (personalised goods, for example). The arrangements (who pays for the return) are described on the seller's site.
  • Statutory conformity guarantee. A product that does not match what was advertised (a “natural” stone that is glass) may entitle you to repair, replacement or refund, within a guarantee period of at least two years under the European rule.
  • Consumer information. The seller must provide the essential characteristics of the product. For stones, decree no. 2002-65 of 14 January 2002 governs the names and the disclosure of certain treatments.
  • Where to report a problem. The official SignalConso platform, run by the DGCCRF, lets you report a dubious commercial practice; the site service-public.fr explains the procedures.

Keep screenshots of the listing as it was when you bought, the order confirmation and your exchanges with the seller. Prefer a payment method that offers recourse in case of dispute.

On arrival: what to do straight away

  1. Photograph the packaging and the unwrapping if the piece looks damaged.
  2. Compare it with the listing: dimensions with a ruler, weight on a kitchen scale, appearance in daylight.
  3. Examine it under a loupe (10x magnification): round bubbles, colour in the fractures, a coating that is flaking, a join line on the side.
  4. Carry out the safe tests described in our guides (see testing a stone): never acid, flame, solvent or deep scratching.
  5. Write to the seller within the time limit if anything does not match the listing, attaching photos.
  6. Keep the packaging until you are satisfied.

These tests do not replace a laboratory. For a valuable piece, ask for a report from a recognised laboratory before paying, or arrange for one to be made during the withdrawal period.

Our approach

We are not immune to the same limits as any online seller: the photo of a natural stone is indicative, and the piece you receive may differ slightly. Our commitments are to state the material of each product, not to sell glass or resin under the name of a stone, to disclose treatments communicated by our supplier, and to give you 14 days to change your mind. See our commitments, delivery and our contact details. To choose between a rough or a polished stone: rough or polished stone?.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell whether an online stone shop is reliable?

Look for complete legal notices, a precise nature for each stone, dimensions and weights, clear return conditions and detailed reviews on third-party sites. Ask a question before buying and pay attention to the quality of the answer.

Is a photo enough to judge a stone?

No. Colour depends on the screen and lighting, and size, weight and transparency cannot be seen. Use the photo together with the written listing, and ask for a photo of the exact piece for an important purchase.

Can I return a stone that does not look like the photo?

As a general rule, distance selling gives a withdrawal period of at least 14 days. If the piece does not match what was advertised, the statutory conformity guarantee may also apply. Check the shop's conditions.

Is a certificate of authenticity reliable?

Only if it is issued by a recognised gemmological laboratory and identifies the specific piece. A paper from the seller does not replace an independent appraisal.

Where can I report a dubious seller or listing?

In France, on SignalConso, the official platform of the DGCCRF, or with the departmental directorate responsible for consumer protection.

Also read

The meanings mentioned belong to tradition and symbolism. They are neither promises of results nor medical advice. Back to Recognizing real stones.

Photo: Robert M. Lavinsky, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0